Mostrar mensagens com a etiqueta Doug Koplow. Mostrar todas as mensagens
Mostrar mensagens com a etiqueta Doug Koplow. Mostrar todas as mensagens

quarta-feira, 19 de junho de 2024

Government Subsidies to Planet-Harming Sectors Surpass $2.6T, Going Against Global Climate Goals


Since 2022, environmentally harmful subsidies from governments have risen by roughly $800B, now accounting for 2.5% of the world’s GDP each year.

Despite pledging to repurpose at least $500B of planet-harming subsidies a year by 2030, governments around the world have poured $800B more into fossil fuels, deforestation and water pollution, new research has found.

Since 2022, when the Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework was signed, countries’ contributions to climate-destroying sectors have crossed $2.6T, or 2.5% of the global GDP, per year.

Governments have been granting subsidies, tax breaks, below-market leases and other funds to activities that go against the promises they made at the biodiversity COP15 in Montreal two years ago, the report by the organisation Earth Track revealed.

“Despite 196 governments agreeing to reform harmful subsidies in 2022, progress has been too slow. We’re spending more than ever on subsidies that are unintentionally destroying the planet on which all our livelihoods and economies depend,” said Eva Zabey, CEO of Business for Nature, a global coalition of conversation agencies.

Fossil fuel use drives rise in climate-harming subsidies
Doug Koplow and Ronald Steenblik are leading experts on government subsidies relating to the environment, and their latest work is an update on their review from 2022, which incorporated multiple sectors affecting resource extraction and land use change.

The authors argue that most international analyses of subsidies are too focused on a single sector, but it’s in fact the combined effect that drives nature and biodiversity loss. In the new report, they have included estimates from non-energy mining and plastics production.

This – combined with improved data, inflation, and rising fossil fuel subsidies – primarily led to the $800B hike. When adjusted for inflation, this increase amounts to $570B.

The fossil fuel sector saw the largest spike, with subsidies up by an average of $340B a year owing to the war in Ukraine and consequent energy price surges. Government subsidies towards carbon capture and sequestration, as well as energy stockpiling, took the sector’s annual total to $1.05T.

The report notes that fossil fuel subsidies represented over 10 times the total revenues from carbon pricing schemes. Meanwhile, additional large-scale funding of international fossil fuel projects via public lenders provided nearly $50B a year during 2020-22 – lending has been “heavily skewed” towards oil and gas over clean energy.

At $600B, agriculture received the second-largest share of annual subsidies. Total subsidies are actually much higher, but much of this funding went to support food security, so isn’t considered planet-harming. Still, the farming sector saw a $25B hike in public subsidies, mostly for monoculture and biofuels.

The fishing industry was the recipient of $55B in subsidies, geared towards large fisheries that promote overfishing and are linked to illegal, unregulated, and unreported catch. Subsidies towards water totalled $390B, going towards direct freshwater withdrawal for agriculture (71% of the share) and industry (16%). Only 6% of these subsidies benefit the lowest income quintile.

Other harmful industries that have benefitted from state support include transportation ($180B in subsidies), forestry ($175M), construction ($150B), non-energy mining ($40B), and plastics ($30B).

Governments must deliver on subsidy reform promise at COP16
At COP15, governments pledged to redirect subsidies worth half a trillion towards policies that benefit people and the planet, as part of the Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework.

In the text of Target 18, governments vowed to “identify by 2025, and eliminate, phase out or reform incentives, including subsidies, harmful for biodiversity, in a proportionate, just, fair, effective and equitable way, while substantially and progressively reducing them by at least $500B by 2030”. They said they would start with the “most harmful incentives, and scale up positive incentives for the conservation and sustainable use of biodiversity”.

The numbers from this Earth Track’s report show that these promises aren’t on track. And that’s before you realise that the figures were likely an underestimate due to the lack of high-quality data.

That said, some governments have begun to assess the impact of these subsidies. The Netherlands has published a report on food and nature subsidies and their impact on biodiversity, Brazil’s federal audit court is examining whether the country is prepared to repurpose subsidies, and the EU has produced a draft methodology for subsidy reform.

To help governments advance their efforts, Business for Nature has published a list of ways to implement Target 18. It’s asking countries to conduct national assessments to identify the scale and types of subsidy mechanisms, co-develop and publish a robust reform roadmap, and redirect planet-harming subsidies while ensuring a just transition and bolstering social purposes.

Countries should also enhance accountability and governance of such policies, and advance international cooperation on the issue. Governments will meet at COP16 in Colombia next month, and they’re being urged to keep the promises they made in the last biodiversity summit.

“With COP16 fast approaching, it’s time for governments to ditch these harmful subsidies and redirect them to accelerate the transition to a nature-positive economy for all,” said Zabey. “Businesses have an important role to play, starting by assessing their dependencies and actively supporting governments in their reform efforts.”

Meanwhile, food awareness organisation ProVeg International is calling on world leaders to recognise the potential of food system change, which it says should be the leading strategy to stop Amazonian deforestation.

“We really hope to get this message across at the biodiversity summit in Colombia in a way that inspires countries to take concrete action and introduce policies that will save our precious wildlife,” said Laura Weidgenant, the non-profit’s senior UN policy manager.

sexta-feira, 13 de janeiro de 2023

Tax Expenditure Scrutiny Can End Trillion-Dollar Political Game


Tax expenditures should be scrutinized as much as direct spending but are often under-reported, if reported at all. Improving estimates and reporting of such outlays would ease budget constraints and help governments better align their core policy objectives, say Flurim Aliu and Agustin Redonda of the Council on Economic Policies and Doug Koplow of Earth Track.

Though a quarter-century old, the federal child tax credit has been the subject of increased debate in recent years within the United States. Conservatives highlight its large fiscal cost while proponents focus on its effectiveness in fighting child poverty. Both camps rely on a significant amount of data on the cost and impacts of the provision.

This type of data is missing for many tax breaks in the US and is lacking entirely in many countries. When it comes to evaluating the scope, size, and impact of tax expenditures, policy makers are most often driving blind.

Too often, government spending is understood only as cash payments to specific individuals or groups. However, targeted exemptions or reductions in taxes owed strain public coffers similarly to direct spending, though often with far less visibility.

This type of outlay, referred to as tax expenditures, is used widely, and the resulting loss in revenue flowing into Treasuries (revenue forgone) is surprisingly large. In fiscal 2021, for example, income-related federal tax expenditures in the US amounted to $1.4 trillion in revenue forgone—a figure equal to more than 20% of the $6.8 trillion in federal direct spending during that same period.

Perhaps even more sobering, the lost revenue from tax breaks were equal to roughly 70% of the $2.1 trillion in federal tax revenue collected, or about 6% of GDP. They nearly equaled the $1.6 trillion in total federal discretionary spending that year, a category that includes key government support for defense, food and agriculture, energy and environment, transportation, and education.

The US is not an outlier—2020 tax expenditures amounted to 14.2% of GDP in the Netherlands and 10.4% in Ireland. During the same year, Canada and the UK logged revenue losses comparable to the US at 6.5% and 8.1% of GDP, respectively. Average revenue losses globally approach 4% of yearly GDP.

Similar to direct spending programs, tax expenditures are used to pursue a variety of policy goals, including regional development, attracting foreign direct investment, greening the economy, or mitigating inequality and poverty. And like those spending programs, tax expenditure provisions can be politically influenced or poorly structured such that they end up supporting non-target groups or generating windfall gains to the wealthy.

The big difference across these two areas is in terms of transparency, and that needs to change. Assessing the scale of support, the main beneficiaries, and the effectiveness of a tax break in achieving its stated policy goals are critical to ensure the efficient use of public resources.

The scope and degree of detail of the Canadian Tax Expenditure report provides a useful model. Capturing not just basic information on each provision and why it is classified as a tax break, Canada also links revenue forgone estimates to policy goals and the standard functions of government, recognizing that tax expenditures and direct spending are often interchangeable policy strategies. Further, the Canadian report on federal tax expenditures includes references to specific evaluations of tax breaks. The 2021 report, for example, included a cost-benefit assessment of subsidies to childcare.

Transparency Challenges
Unfortunately, we are far from achieving even a minimal level of transparency. The Global Tax Expenditures Database is the most comprehensive tally of tax expenditures in the world, gathering all available tax expenditure information published by national governments worldwide since 1990. Yet, among the 218 countries it tracks, more than half—116—are classified as non-reporting against the low bar of having released at least one official tax expenditure report within the last three decades.

Even among the 102 reporting countries, the quality and scope of the information provided varies significantly and is often quite limited. For example, of nearly 23,000 tax expenditure provisions currently captured within the GTED from national-level data, 30% included no estimate for the associated revenue forgone. This is a critical value to assess the magnitude of the tax breaks and prioritize reform. Yet, of the roughly 16,000 provisions that do contain a revenue loss estimate, 60% don’t disclose the policy goal that they were implemented to achieve, making evaluations of policy efficacy near impossible.

Under-reporting is a pervasive problem. The latest TE report of the UK, for example, lacks revenue forgone values for more than 30% of its reported tax expenditure provisions. While the report lists six broad reasons for this gap, they are generic, such as lack of data, confidentiality issues, and the rather unhelpful category of “other.”

An even bleaker scenario arises with sub-national reporting and disclosure. Initial data reviews of OECD’s fossil fuel subsidy database indicate that sub-national tax breaks supporting the production and consumption of fossil fuels are significant in many countries. These sub-national subsidies often are reported sporadically or not at all.

The US is an exception. Most states report on tax expenditures with disclosure that compares favorably even with national tax expenditure reports in many other countries. A detailed inspection, however, shows that important gaps remain. For instance, the lack of transparency and data tracking between federal and state opportunity zone programs renders proper evaluation of the total taxpayer subsidy to construction projects impossible.

Another example is a legislative loophole for mandatory tax expenditure reporting in Texas that enables large exemptions from smaller tax bases to be excluded, even if they result in substantial losses to state taxpayers. The result is that the single largest tax break to natural gas, worth more than $1 billion in 2022, didn’t have to be included in the report.

Tax expenditures should be subject to as much scrutiny as direct spending. Indeed, the opacity of tax expenditure beneficiaries creates political pressures to increase the public resources directed in this way because the political costs to both recipients and their political supporters are lower. Improving tax expenditure estimation and reporting would ease budget constraints and allow the design of tax expenditures that better align with the government’s core policy objectives.

sexta-feira, 18 de fevereiro de 2022

World Spent $1.8tn A Year on Subsidies Contributing to Environmental Pollution


New research warns that humanity is funding its own extinction as nearly 2% of the global GDP goes towards industries doing the most environmental pollution.

Governments worldwide are spending at least USD$1.8 trillion a year on subsidies to support heavy polluting industries including coal, oil, gas, and agriculture, driving further environmental pollution and degradation, as well as biodiversity loss, according to a new independent research.

In a first cross-sector assessment for more than a decade, independent researchers Doug Koplow and Ronald Steenblik, who are both leading experts on subsidies, have found that about 2% of the global gross domestic product (GDP) was spent every year on encouraging and supporting unsustainable production and consumption.

The biggest beneficiary of government handouts by far was the fossil fuel industry, which received $640 billion a year, while the agricultural and forestry sectors were given $520 billion and $155 billion, respectively. The duo were unable to provide an estimate for the mining industry, but it is believed that the sector causes billions of dollars worth of damage to natural ecosystems. They also note that these estimates are likely on the conservative side as the existence and size of governmental subsidies were not always reported.

The two researchers concluded that the world is essentially financing its own extinction as governments continue to pay industries driving environmental pollution, depleting natural resources, contributing towards biodiversity loss with harmful activities such as water pollution and deforestation, and working against the goals set out in the Paris Agreement – to limit global temperature rise to 1.5-2 degree Celsius above pre-industrial levels.

Separate data published the International Energy Agency showed Iran, China and India gave out the most in fossil fuel consumption subsidies in 2019, at $87.9bn, $34bn and $33bn, respectively. In 2021, the UN also found that nearly 90% of global farming subsidies are contributing significant amounts of greenhouse gas emissions, directly harming public health, fuelling the climate crisis, as well as hurting smallholder farmers.

Combined with the latest damning research, they undermine the pledge made by nearly 200 countries at the COP26 climate summit agreeing to “phase down” coal by phasing out “inefficient fossil fuel subsidies”. But the UN conference failed to put down a concrete timeline to do so.

Authors of the report say a majority of the current $1.8 trillion fossil fuel and agricultural subsidies could be repurposed to support the global net zero strategy, amid growing costs in renewable energy due to travel restrictions and global supply chain issues caused by the pandemic.

The report also calls for governments to agree on a target to eradicate environmentally harmful subsidies by the end of the decade at the biodiversity Cop15 conference in China later this year, pushing for companies to disclose the subsidies that they receive. Since they were established in 2011, no country in the world has successfully met the Aichi Biodiversity Targets, which sets out specific goals in addressing biodiversity loss.

Christiana Figueres, who was head of the UN climate change convention when the Paris agreement was signed, agrees with the report findings and its recommendations.

“Nature is declining at an alarming rate, and we have never lived on a planet with so little biodiversity,” said Figueres. “Harmful subsidies must be redirected towards protecting the climate and nature, rather than financing our own extinction.”

You might also like: 

terça-feira, 24 de agosto de 2021

The nuclearization of space


By Karl Grossman

“BACK TO THE FUTURE NASA’S NEW NUCLEAR VISION” was the headline emblazoned on the cover of the May 3-16, 2021 edition of the leading U.S. aerospace trade publication, Aviation Week & Space Technology.

“More than sixty years after the U.S. began serious studies into nuclear propulsion for space travel, NASA is taking the first steps on a new path to develop nuclear-powered engines for crewed missions to Mars by the end of the next decade,” it began.

“Nuclear enabled space vehicles would allow NASA to keep the round-trip crewed Mars mission duration to about two years, versus more than three years with the best chemical rockets and even longer with solar electric propulsion,” the extensive five-page piece declared.

Also, it said, “other factors strengthening the case for nuclear power include growing interest from the Defense Department in using the technology to extend operational capability in space.”

Further, nuclear power—either through nuclear thermal propulsion (NTP) or nuclear electric propulsion (NEP)—would “provide power for future crewed and robotic deep-space exploration missions as well as faster, more responsive resupply flights to lunar and Martian outposts.”

The article was accompanied by a two-page addition providing a military link. “Draco Embarks on Quest To Revive Nuclear Space Propulsion,” was the headline of this piece. Draco stands for “Demonstration Rocket for Agile Cislunar Operations.” It’s a program of the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA), a U.S. Department of Defense agency that develops technologies for the military.

Space News, another major U.S. aerospace publication, two weeks later ran a two-page piece headlined: “America’s future in space is nuclear.”

Authored by John M. Horack, the Neil Armstrong Chair in Aerospace Policy at Ohio State University, he previously worked for almost two decades at NASA and led the Science and Mission Systems Office at NASA’s Space Flight Center.

Horack wrote: “Today, we have a unique opportunity to make the entire solar system—including the strategically vital regions of space surrounding the Earth and the moon—more accessible, through investments in advanced propulsion systems…Nuclear thermal propulsion is the most promising technology to accomplish these goals.” It “will enable the U.S. to ‘sail’ the ocean of space with greater efficiency, capability, and autonomy, thereby exercising and helping secure our leadership position in civil and national security spaceflight activities.”

These are “dangerous plans for full-blown nukes in space,” declares Bruce Gagnon, coordinator of the Global Network Against Weapons and Nuclear Power in Space.

They translate to “high-risk for those of us on Earth below as nuclear reactors are launched on rockets that blow up from time to time,” said Gagnon. Moreover, although there are no cost estimates included in any of the trade journal pieces, Gagnon asks: “Where will those funds come from? Maybe from the budget that helps deal with our current climate crisis here on Mother Earth.”

Established in 1992, the Global Network, based in Maine, is the leading group internationally challenging the use of nuclear power in space.

The “BACK TO THE FUTURE” reference in the main Aviation Week & Space Technology article refers to, as it notes, how “the new program will also leverage knowledge gained as far back as the 1955-73 Atomic Energy Commission’s Project Rover and 1961-73 NASA Nuclear Engine for Rocket Vehicle Application program.” These projects “were canceled as funding priorities shifted.”

“The benefits of space nuclear propulsion are as attractive as the challenges are daunting,” said the piece. “Although offering faster trip times…the practicality of integrating a fission reactor into a viable propulsion system will require significant technological advances, particularly in materials in fuel. The solid core reactor—the configuration most likely to be used in near-term NTP designs—can create much higher temperatures than conventional materials can withstand. Additionally, fuel coatings can crack because of large temperature variations along fuel rods, lowering performance.”

“So,” asks the piece, “with these ever-prevent challenges still an obstacle, is NASA’s new nuclear space plan more realistic than previous attempts?”

In response, it quotes Anthony Calomino, whom it identifies as nuclear technology portfolio lead in NASA’s Space Technology Mission Directorate, saying: “The need case for the technology has changed in the last few decades, particularly with NASA’s focus on developing the capabilities for Mars missions.”
The additional piece with the military link starts off: “A nebulously named ‘Deterrence Layer’ is on the drawing board for the National Defense Space Architecture, and that could mean the return of a functioning U.S. operated, nuclear-powered satellite in orbit by 2025 for the first time in 60 years.”

“The idea of nuclear-powered space flight by the military is hardly original to Draco,” it states. “The U.S. Air Force operated the 950-lb. Systems for Nuclear Auxiliary Power (SNAP-10A) satellite which used an onboard nuclear reactor to generate at least 500 watts of electricity for 43 days in 1965 until the failure of a nonpropulsive component. Although no longer in service, the SNAP-10A reactor is expected to remain in orbit for the next 3,000 years.” SNAP-10A was fueled with uranium.

Not mentioned by Aviation Week & Space Technology was an accident the year earlier—involving a radioisotope thermoelectric generator, SNAP-9A, not a reactor but a device utilizing heat from the breakdown of plutonium to produce electricity. The satellite on which it was to provide power failed to attain orbit and crashed back into the atmosphere, the plutonium in SNAP-9A dispersing and spreading widely on Earth.

Dr. John Gofman, an M.D. and Ph.D. involved in the isolation of plutonium during the Manhattan Project and long a professor of medical physics at the University of California at Berkeley, connected the SNAP-9A accident with a spike in lung cancer on Earth.

The article went on: “Twenty years after the launch of SNAP-10A, the Strategic Defense Initiative revived the nuclear-powered rocket concept as a proposal for the upper stage of a boost-phase intercept that would shoot down intercontinental ballistic missiles over the Soviet Union from Alaska. As the Cold War ended, the so-called Timberwind project was transferred to the Air Force to pursue as a science experiment, but it was cancelled in 1994 before a reactor could be tested.”

The article also declares: “Concerns about launching a nuclear reactor into space have persisted for decades.”

A NASA webinar on U.S. space nuclear plans was held earlier this year, relates Gagnon, which emphasized how the U.S. is moving ahead with not only schemes for nuclear propulsion in space but for plans for “full nuclearization” of colonies on the moon, Mars “and in other planetary colonization.”

The public relations slogan being advanced, Gagnon said, was that the space nuclear activities would be “’clean and reliable.’ That’s a laugh. Say it often enough and the public might begin to believe it.”

Gagnon said the nuclear reactors for placement on the moon were described in the NASA webinar as having a “10-year life-cycle, which would mean frequent launches of these nuclear reactors.” And, he noted, one out of 100 rocket launches have historically resulted in a major malfunction, usually the rocket blowing up.

Further, nuclear operations on the moon were described as “working out the kinks for the Mars missions.” Said Gagnon: “So it is more than clear that this entire program is one very dangerous experiment.”

Meanwhile, continued Gagnon, “Little is said about the national Department of Energy nuclear labs where they fabricate space nuclear devices. Over the years we’ve learned that these labs have a long and dirty track record of accidental worker and local water/air contamination of uranium and plutonium.

“The nuclear industry clearly is interested in hitching a ride,” said Gagnon, “as it eyes the opportunity to put its toxic product on the moon, Mars and on rockets to the red planet. The DoE and NASA plan to cut as many corners as possible on testing and funding and lessen public scrutiny of these deadly projects. For those of us who have been tracking the nuclear space industry for many years, the alarm bells are clanging in our ears. It would be the right time for inquiring people to raise questions, challenge untested assumptions, and warn an unsuspecting public about the dangers of the nuclearization of the heavens.”

The SNAP-9A and SNAP-10 space mishaps spurred NASA in pioneering solar power for satellites. Now, all satellites utilize solar energy as does the International Space Station.

But despite claiming for decades that nuclear power was needed for space probes, NASA used three solar photovoltaic panels on its Juno space probe, which in 2016 reached Jupiter. Juno is still up there, orbiting and studying the solar system’s largest planet, at which sunlight is a hundredth of what it is on Earth.

There have been studies and articles through the years pointing to solar power as an energy source for moon and Mars colonies including a piece in Universe Today headed “Solar Power Is Best for Mars Colonies.”

And a Discover magazine piece, “How to Harvest Terawatts of Solar Power on the Moon,” spoke of the Japanese corporation, Shimizu, “gearing up to develop solar power on the moon.” The “photovoltaic cells themselves could be tissue thin, since the moon has no weather or air,” said the article, “and half of the moon is in sunlight at any one time.” Indeed, said the article, a huge amount of solar power energy could be generated on the moon and be beamed back to Earth.

Karl Grossman is professor of journalism at State University of New York/College at Old Westbury, and is the author of the book, The Wrong Stuff: The Space’s Program’s Nuclear Threat to Our Planet, and the Beyond Nuclear handbook, The U.S. Space Force and the dangers of nuclear power and nuclear war in space. Grossman is a board member of Beyond Nuclear and an associate of the media watch group Fairness and Accuracy in Reporting (FAIR). He is a contributor to Hopeless: Barack Obama and the Politics of Illusion.

domingo, 25 de abril de 2010

São trabalhadores precários que fazem o trabalho sujo e mais perigoso nas centrais nucleares


As centrais atómicas francesas recorrem a trabalhadores precários, frequentemente sem residência fixa, empregados nas tarefas mais arriscadas e mais expostas às radiações.

Chamam-lhes 'jumpers', os que mergulham para dentro do reactor. Ou nómadas do nuclear",
lê-se no Alias, o suplemento semanal do diário italiano Il Manifesto.

Empregados por subcontratantes da EDF, GDF-Suez ou Areva, as empresas que gerem as centrais, "incorporam 80% das doses colectivas anuais de radiações ionizantes produzidas pelo parque nuclear francês".

A revista explica que a doutrina do “risco zero” em matéria de protecção das radiações foi progressivamente abandonada, trocada pela muito mais leve ALARA (As Low As Reasonably Acceptable, o mais baixo razoavelmente aceitável).

Vários destes "nómadas nucleares" apresentaram queixa contra os seus empregadores devido às consequências da sua exposição às radiações; mas não tiveram seguimento, porque a prescrição para os acidentes do trabalho no domínio nuclear é de dez anos, "o tempo de incubar a doença e de ocultar as causas que a provocaram", sublinha o Alias.

Entretanto descobri uma entrevista,  da Global Subsidies Initiative (GSI) a Doug Koplow, fundador do Earth Track  (obrigatório ler).

Nela refere que a indústria nuclear é altamente subsidiada, e que mesmo se esta indústria reduz as emissões de CO2, trata-se de uma falácia, pois os custos são muito elevados.Refere o exemplo do fiasco da mais moderna central nuclear na Finlândia [
ler aqui notícia mais detalhada].

O especialista denuncia também a ligação entre o nuclear civil e a proliferação de armamento nuclear.

Ainda de acordo com Doug Koplow a direcção correcta a dar aos mercados é investir em várias outras fontes alternativas de energia e melhorar a eficiência energética.